- 45
- Sphinn It!
Posted By: rustybrick 222 days ago
Topic Type: News Story (Jump to http://www.seroundtable.com)
Category: Link Building
12 Comments
12 Comments
Save the date for:
SMX Local & Mobile - San Francisco, CA (July 24-25) See the agenda, and register now!
SMX Sao Paolo - Brazil - (Aug. 7-8)
SMX China - September 23 & 24, 2008
SMX Stockholm - September 23 & 24, 2008
SMX East - NYC - (Oct. 6-8) Registration is now open.
SMX London - November 4 & 5, 2008
Comments
Not exactly paid links ...
More like a "testimonials" page than anything else. Plus way to many links to really benefit that much from PageRank imo.
But how would Matt Cutts see those links?
I think the same way. If he were to view the links on that page as "paid links" then testimonial pages everywhere would be suspect.
David, soon soon. I wouldn't doubt that happening...
I think this is a classic case of the "grey link". All around the internet you'll see links which have occurred because of a financial relationship. Google will look at the stats; Google.com doesn't seem to be selling links and many of the sites listed on the page won't have the link buying signature - as a result these links will count. Links which appear on the web due to other financial relationships and where the buyer/sellers don't seem to be engaging in link buying will also count.
Matt disabled PageRank flow from similar links in the past. Probably he did it already just to make sure that such accusations are deniable. It's a shame.
Once again we are dealing with Google's supposed ability to devine what the intent of links are. If someone buys this mini thing just so they can get that PR7 link, then it should be nofollowed (according to their rules) but if they are only buying the product and the link is extra it shouldn't.
They really opened up this mess themselves when for some unexplainable reason they let the Yahoo! directory continue. You're paying $299 for a review not a link, in their view, not unlike Barry's example.
So all of you link sellers and directories out there, stop selling links, but sell 1-page ebooks instead and have a "list" of all your satisfied customers organized by category. Seems fair to me, it's okay for Google and Yahoo! to sell their services and acknowledge their customers with a non-nofollowed link.
Now, if tomorrow some of those links are nofollowed and some are not, we'll know that GOOG has the ability to understand intent.
I checked www.bilia.se for backlinks, nothing from Google, showing as a link in Yahoo and MSN.
I would love to hear Matt's perspective on these links! Looks kind of like a link farm to me.
Pittfall
I did the same, no backlinks showing up from Google
Google doesn't show the link love
It's rather old news isn't it...
Skitzzo, yes, in my article, I wrote it is old news. Part of the point...