Sorry this site requires JavaScript to be enabled in your browser. See the following guide on How to enable JavaScript in Internet Explorer, Netscape, Firefox and Safari. Alternatively you may be blocking JavaScript with an advert-related or developer plugin. Please check your browser plugins.

Google accuses Bing of copying its search results. Bing calls Google's sting operation a "spy-novelesque stunt." Google fires back by calling Bing's search results a "cheap imitation" and a "recycled" version of Google's search results. Now that the dust is settling a day later, our "Discussion of the Week" asks a simple question: Who won ... Google or Bing? (And yes, there are many ways you can take that question and run with it, so go for it!)
Comments9 Comments  

Comments

Avatar Moderator
from JulieJoyce 1418 Days ago #
Votes: 4

Blekko.



Avatar Moderator
from Realicity 1418 Days ago #
Votes: 1

Have to agree with Julie!

1st place is probably Blekko. They gained some attention and from the PR side, they did not come off in a negative way.

2nd place is Bing.  They proved to be clever and resourceful (whether you are on their side or against) and seemed to calmly take the criticism well.  They will recover from the PR hit when more people actually learn more of the facts and not just the headlines.

3rd place goes to Google for throwing over-hyped and very misleading accusations while spinning the data and presenting it in a disingenuous way.

4th & last place is Ask.com for not capitalizing one the opportunity to gain some PR and remaining lost in the search space.

Also, if I have a 1B winner, it is Search Engine Land for the great posts.



Avatar
from SeanWF 1418 Days ago #
Votes: 1

Google won for people who just read the headlines, or who don't have a thorough understanding of the issues, technical aspects, or precedent.

Google lost for anyone not in the above group, although I have a hard time saying that Bing "won."



Avatar Moderator
from toddmintz 1418 Days ago #
Votes: 1

I think it was a draw and I believe nobody outside of this community really cares that much.

This whole episode reminded me of dueling political ads where the commercials tried to hammer points home that ultimately weren't that important to great majority of the people.



Avatar Administrator
from Michelle 1418 Days ago #
Votes: 1

I think Bing is the winner. What really came out of this whole affair is the fact that Google is in fact, very concerned with Bing and what it does, and it's competitive threat. It looks surprisingly paranoid to me.


Even more ironic is the notion from Google that Bing's results are cheap imitations of their own. I suppose they've forgotten what the prototype Android phone looked like (it wasn't a touchscreen device). Apple provided them with their final model. And Schmidt sat on that board while Apple developed it.  So Google pointing fingers and making accusations of "copying" is about the height of hypocrisy.




Avatar Moderator
from ajkohn2001 1418 Days ago #
Votes: 0

I think outside of our community (e.g. - the majority of the world) Google probably won. Google already has a positive perception so describing Bing as cheating or copying would reinforce the perception that Google has the best results.

Within the community I think Google lost. There was just too much PR behind this and the moralistic 'gotcha' just doesn't really sit well. I don't think Bing won but at least they weren't wearing mint shoes.

I actually think Blekko lost. I see little sense (from a business or consumer standpoint) to censoring the entire experience (for everyone) based on personal spam complaints from a group of technology innovators. Rank those sites lower if you wish, but removing them is simple censorship as far as I'm concerned.



Avatar
from seotheory 1418 Days ago #
Votes: 1

Everyone lost.  Google has spent the last week trying to undermine a foreign government (Egypt) and a rival search engine.  What on Earth are they thinking?



Avatar
from JonathanBeaton 1418 Days ago #
Votes: 0

I just don't see what Google is complaining about?

The fact Bing can steal their search results is more of a negative reflection on Google's business model than it is Bing's.

This just means that Google's algorithm is not as defensible as they thought it was. Tough shit.



Avatar Moderator
from Jill 1417 Days ago #
Votes: 0

Upcoming Conferences

Search Marketing ExpoSearch Engine Land produces SMX, the Search Marketing Expo conference series. SMX events deliver the most comprehensive educational and networking experiences - whether you're just starting in search marketing or you're a seasoned expert.



Join us at an upcoming SMX event: