Sphinn
What's Sphinn?  |  Join us!  |  Login  | Help | Tools

  • Hot Topics
  • What's New
  • Greatest Hits
  • Comments
  • Submit
  • Calendar
  • Network
  • Feeds
  • Search Engine Land
  • All Categories
  • Google
  • Yahoo
  • Microsoft
  • Search Marketing
  • Social Media
  • Online Marketing
  • Searching
  • Other
  •      :: Sphinn Live ::

Sphinn Home » Google Other
  • 37
  • Sphinn It!
Apparently Someone At Google Has A Twisted Sense of Humor
Avatar Went Hot: January 24, 2008 - 2:23 pm
Posted By: aimClear 114 days ago
Topic Type: News Story (Jump to http://www.capecodseo.com) my network
Category: Google Other
For the short term, it appears that Google has had the last laugh. Read this wacky index switcheroo case study from CapeCodSEO.
6 Comments     

  • Comments
  • Who Sphunn This (37)
  • Who Desphunn This (0)

Comments

from g1smd 114 days ago #
Votes: 0 | Vote:
+ -

The post you blocked. Does it have more than one URL that can access it?  Did a different URL for it get indexed?


Did you block it in robots.txt a day or two before publishing it?  If not, Google can find a page and index it, and only later, perhaps next day, get the newer version of robots.txt that was supposed to block it, and then take a day or two to drop it from the results.

That happens a lot.

Check the Google cache date, and then check your site logs for the date and time that Google fetched the  robots.txt  file.

from dedmond29 114 days ago #
Votes: 0 | Vote:
+ -

g1smd - thanks for taking the time to comment and make suggestions.  Its completely appreciated.  I am pretty certain I uploaded the new robots file in coordination with the post - and have since simply removed the block.

I also tweaked a couple other things and we'll see what happens. 

Your comments did get me thinking about checking Google's index of the site in greater detail and it does appear that I need to spend a bit more time on this. 

Interestingly enough, more pages have now been removed (since this morning - including the sitemap page), although Google Blog Search has indexed all posts as appropriate. 

The funny thing is - I don't even receive a substantial amount of Google traffic (now have I ever) but can't really NOT rank this blog for a select group of keywords. Sigh.

Thanks again for the time.

from g1smd 114 days ago #
Votes: 0 | Vote:
+ -

Google doesn't always fetch the robots.txt file before fetching new content, and even when they do fetch it they can take several days to act on it, and even longer to deindex stuff they have already listed. Nothing is instantaneous, and stuff that you thought secret can be easily leaked by doing things in the wrong order.  Different search engies also do things in slightly different ways too.  There's no easy answer.  :-)

from MattCutts 113 days ago #
Votes: 1 | Vote:
+ -

g1smd, that's what I was thinking too. Any time I hear "I blocked Google from one post, and then the root page disappeared" it often turns out to be related. I did a three-second check to verify that the webspam team had nothing to do with it.

from dedmond29 113 days ago #
Votes: 0 | Vote:
+ -

@MattCutts, g1smd - thanks for the replies and the quick check.  I didn't really think there was/is some form of conspiracy going on here - but it was fun to write about (sorry). 

I also did not consider the relationship between search engine crawl rates, robot.txt files and timing.  That is a really interesting point of reference and something to pay attention to in the future. 

Thanks again!

from g1smd 113 days ago #
Votes: 0 | Vote:
+ -

I have learnt to upload a new robots.txt about a week before the URLs that are needed to be blocked go live.


Log in to comment or register here.

Who Sphunn This Topic?

  1. Avatar toddmintz
  2. Avatar mpilatow
  3. Avatar seosuresh
  4. Avatar Herbert
  5. Avatar northrock
  6. Avatar dedmond29
  7. Avatar UtahSEOpro
  8. Avatar Harith
  9. Avatar aimClear
  10. Avatar vangogh
  11. Avatar pittfall
  12. Avatar jeffquipp
  13. Avatar vandelay
  14. Avatar ViperChill
  15. Avatar SearchBuzz
  16. Avatar nowsourcing
  17. Avatar g1smd
  18. Avatar sherwood
  19. Avatar akomack
  20. Avatar casieg
  21. Avatar TripleAught
  22. Avatar SexySEO
  23. Avatar TheNanny612
  24. Avatar planetc1
  25. Avatar SeoDesignSolutions
  26. Avatar TannerHobin
  27. Avatar ljs4iu
  28. Avatar Ruud
  29. Avatar theGypsy
  30. Avatar swags2804
  31. Avatar rabeidoh
  32. Avatar baiduyou
  33. Avatar gunjanpandya
  34. Avatar mban23
  35. Avatar kevinheisler
  36. Avatar jameszol
  37. Avatar managementaccountant

Who Desphunn This Topic what is desphinn?

Related Links

There are no related links for this story.

Top 10 Most Sphunn
In What's New

  1. Baby Girl Born on Twitter! (20)
  2. 9 Tips To Gain Exposure (19)
  3. Search Industry Productivity Increa... (19)
  4. SecondBrain - The First Complete So... (19)
  5. The 25 Most Popular Pages on Facebo... (19)
  6. Community: The Human Element of SEO... (18)
  7. Search Marketing Trends - What's up... (18)
  8. Tips for Building Communities, Onli... (17)
  9. 20 Useful Tools to Make Web Develop... (15)
  10. Peanuts, monkeys, tailors and charg... (15)

Latest Comments

  • Mike, you just made my Xmas card list. ;-)…
  • Lying is illegal and wrong when used as a marketting tool. Illegal at the v…
  • Have to agree with Nick here also. Black Hat should probably be left within…
  • Enough people do think ethics applies to warrant the debate, but as you sai…
  • My first impression... a great resource! Not only will this help me be more…
  • A community where the most 'famous' user is known as Mr Babyman and we're s…
  • @nickwilsdon - better put than I could have managed   …
  • I hadn't noticed that - though Aaron's posts tend to be more business relat…
  • - read more -
Search Marketing Expo

Save the date for:
• SMX Madrid (in Spanish, May 20-21)
• SMX Advanced - Seattle, WA (June 3-4) Register today!
• SMX Local & Mobile - San Francisco, CA (July 24-25) See the agenda, and register now!
• SMX East - NYC - (Oct. 6-8)
• SMX London - November 4 & 5, 2008

©2008 Third Door Media, Inc. Privacy Policy & Terms. All rights reserved.

Contact Us  |  Sphinn Staff     powered by Pligg