Published: Feb 14, 2008 - 07:55 am
Story Found By: daveshap 1460 Days ago
Category: SEM
9 Comments
9 Comments
Search Engine Land produces SMX, the Search Marketing Expo conference series. SMX events deliver the most comprehensive educational and networking experiences - whether you're just starting in search marketing or you're a seasoned expert.
Join us at an upcoming SMX event:
Learn more about search marketing with our free online webcasts and webinars from our sister site, Search Marketing Now. Upcoming online events include:
Comments
Kudos on the post. Its something we all need to think about and decide if we want to take part.
I commented on this on my blog http://www.fionndownhill.com/2008/02/12/online-reputation-management-ethical-or-not/. My advice is stick to solid business ethics and follow your gut. If it walks like a duck, and quacks like a duck and so on.
I think it is a very valid point. I do some reputation management for our resort and vacation rental clients - and one of my mantras is - "I cant make it go away until you FIX it!" There is no amount of PR spin that can hide a truly miserable buisiness or poor business model - although there are those that try - for $29.99 per item Im told :)Great piece!~Carrie
What about managing damaging posts by bitter ex-employees? We did that for a client, an I dont think that is necessarily unethical. So others though have asked to do rather dodgy reputation management, which we politely turned down as it went against our own principles.
Search engines put people in a precarious position where anyone can anonymously make comments that will visibly go on your "permanent record." Unlike credit records or criminal records, there is no real editorial control or official process for having inaccurate information corrected.I think that people have the right to try and improve how they are portrayed in the search results and there there is nothing unethical about increasing the visibility of positive and accurate information about a person or brand. I dont buy into the thinking that says link buying or keyword stuffing is "unethical SEO" - its just SEO that goes against Googles business agenda. As a search marketer, I dont believe that optimizing true information to appear in the search results is "unethical." Its what we all do for a living. And people certainly have the right to monitor (another key part of online reputation management) what others are saying about them and respond appropriately.Ive recently seen a case where a businessmans direct competitor has taken to bashing his product and personal reputation in the search results, and he is being very spiteful and unprofessional about it (calling names, posting his phone number and home address). I think that what the competitor is doing is "unethical."Other examples where reputation management is needed:an ex-employee is making inaccurate, defamatory claims as revenge or retaliationthe person themselves made heated comments or posts in the past that they want to put behind themthere are multiple brands / people of the same name and one wants to avoid confusion and dominatean extortion site like RipOffReport encourages anonymous bashing as a means of making a profitIf Google has the right to maintain a database about us that can contain any information, with no editorial controls or human review... people have a right to try and represent themselves in a positive light and not be stigmatized by anonymous and libelous comments. Its just marketing. Yes, there are some shady people in need to reputation management services. Like FionnD said, you need to decide what campaigns to work on and lend your talent to on a case-by-case basis.If someone is really dishonest or unethical or they are running an ongoing scam.. all the online reputation management in the world wont be able to stop the truth from entering and permeating the search / social media landscape and online conversations.
ya know ya really have to wonder about those companies they mention for example repuation defender Ive ranked top 10 for their name for like a year and half, and its took me about 15 minutes worht of time
Lol @ GraywolfNice one! Someone ought to teach all these cowboys a lesson! They manage to give the entire industry a bad rep and make life tougher for the rest of us.
gray-wolf :dude, Ill give you $29.95 per item to rank assorted pages for me!
Good article. At least, we know if we go beyond to what is required with reputation management, what is ethical and not.