Calendar
Network
Feeds
- 70
- Sphinn It!
News: Flickr Goes Nofollow! Also, Is This The Future of UGC?
Went Hot: February 21, 2008 - 11:15 am
Posted By: Gab 150 days ago
Topic Type: Discussion
Category: Yahoo Other
1) Is this the future of UGC? Contribute, but don't expect any search ranking benefit?
2) Are Yahoo using the nofollow link attribute too?
3) Where's the next best photosharing site that WILL let you get dofollow links? If I'm going to contribute, I want links :P! Real, meaty ones!
4) Can someone please code up a WP plugin to nofollow all links to Flickr? If it could also pull the profile and homepage link of contributors from whom people sourced an image, that would be great [so that you can link directly to their sites and not to flickr.]
5) How is this going to affect retailers doing linkbuilding off Flickr?
Proof for this thread's assertion of auto-nofollowing here:
http://flickr.com/photos/big-e-mr-g/231649733/
http://flickr.com/photos/watchessuperstore/2199515436/
http://www.flickr.com/photos/gabgoldenberg/2232319302/
As an aside, I'd normally post this to my blog, but for whatever reason my laptop won't access the site, nor my host. I encourage you to check it out, in any case - SEOROI.com - and particularly the most recent post on how I didn't make $3000 last week.
16 Comments
Comments
Why am I not suprised after reading this a couple of weeks ago?
http://forum.digeratimarketing.co.uk/viewtopic.php?f=5&t=4
The link's broken eavesy - they killed the thread it seems.
I've been expecting this for months now.. Everywhere you turned there was someone going on about finding high PR pages on flickr to link drop on.. Unfortunately the internet scene has turned in to a "make me rich no matter what it does to anyone else" market.. And it makes good sites do things like this to combat it..
I suppose this was inevitable, but it still sucks. I'll second Gab's call for a WP plugin. If someone can code it, I'd use it.
There was a session at SES San Jose and I believe Chris Silver Smith had a chart about social image sharing sites and what they offered.
23hq.com was on his list and I just tested a text link the photo description and it is NOT nofollowed.
Others on the list I havent tested:
Pbase
Webshots
Fotki
just an observation, not a recommendation ;)
~Carrie
delete amp; to make the link work
Carrie that's something I'll definitely be checking out. Link sources are always interesting. Flickr's different in that they're a Yahoo property though - their decision to change can mean stuff for Yahoo's algo too.
Eavesy, thanks for explaining that... funny quote from that page:
"hi, i can't get this to work?
what am i doing wrong?
The fact that SEOs were targeting Flickr as a place for links tells you right there that Yahoo did the right thing. Now only those who really want to contribute for the right reasons will and those that just want links won't.
Which is as it should be. It's a shame that the Internet just doesn't work that way naturally. More than a shame actually, it's pretty sad.
Still love Flickr, but a WP plugin nofollowing links to the site would seem like the right way to go.
The site may not be useful for link juice any more, but is still great for hosting content and can be a useful online marketing tool for driving traffic/adding depth to your brand
I believe you can still put links into comments in Flickr via for example a smilie image.
Nofollow somehow triggers a NIMBY mentality in alot of people. Its ok if you have nofollow on your blog, but if other people activate nofollow, its evil. That hypocritical SPAM attitude (if I do it, its ok; if you do it and out rank me, you're a cheating scum) is one of the reasons we have nofollow all over the place.
Excellent point Halfdeck..
I find it amazing that the herd mentality of overrunning a site with link drops is seen as a valid way to promote a website.. And when the site being talked about, promoted as a great place to spam links, and generally has it's user area turned in to a link frenzy retaliates by adding a nofollow it's somehow wrong.. Never mind that from now on it will be spammed by people that don't understand, or even care, about the nofollow, they'll just keep right on spamming..
@Jill, thank Google for openly telling people that links are the most important part of ranking..
Its an interesting trend: the more these UGC sites turn on NOFOLLOW to block out spammers the more these links become a valuable representation of what people are actually talking about. If I were Google trying to work out which sites to respect, I would almost start trusting NOFOLLOW links more than the default dofollows.
Links on Flickr's profile pages don't appear to have nofollow on them (yet).
Half, let's be honest here. You are a cheating scumbag [bc you outrank me] :P lol
Here's my image sharing sites chart that Carrie referenced, if you're looking for Flickr alternatives:
http://www.silvery.com/PhotoSharingComparison.html
(I haven't updated the chart in a few months, so you should double-check my notations if you use it.)
I'm sad that Flickr started Nofollowing, but, like Jill, I think that this is probably for the best overall. But, that doesn't negate the overall promotional worth one could get through ethical integration of images in Flickr, as I noted on my blog:
http://www.naturalsearchblog.com/archives/2008/02/21/flickr-starts-nofollowing/
My blog itself actually gets a significant percentage of traffic from Flickr since I've used so many pix hosted on Flickr to illustrate postings.